I followed this webcomic for a while and when there was a kickstarter, I jumped on it, getting all six of the comic collections in one swoop in August 2018. Well, life was crazy, then it got more crazy, then still more and so I never got around to reading this particular books even though they were on my bookstand TBR immediately pile at least four years. Well, the time came to read them since I needed a Male Series Book Review. A delightful task! Plus a bonus in nibbling away at my personal goal of reading more BIPoC authors with twenty-four books to be read in 2024.
If you are academia or writing or science, you might really appreciate these humorous stories and comics. They are dated, especially the early ones, over twenty years have passed since the “cutting” edge of graduate school was first drawn, but they also bring memories back of important events and old technologies.
Created by Dr. Jorge Cham
Chapter 1: Piled Higher and Deeper: A Graduate Comic Strip Collection
Chapter 2: Life is Tough and Then You Graduate
Chapter 3: Scooped!
Chapter 4: Academic Stimulus Package
Chapter 5: Adventures in Thesisland
Chapter 6: 20th Anniversary
Amazon Cover
BOOK BLURB ON AMAZON for PILED HIGHER AND DEEPER
A collection of the first five years of “Piled Higher and Deeper,” the unique and popular comic strip about life (or the lack thereof) in graduate school, as it originally appeared in Stanford University’s “The Stanford Daily Newspaper” and online at www.phdcomics.com “Piled Higher and Deeper” the comic strip is currently published in several newspapers and online, where it is read by grad students from over 1000 universities and colleges in the US and from around the world.
MY REVIEW for PILED HIGHER AND DEEPER
Oh, how many years have I been enjoying this comic? A very long time. This collection is from the early years where the characters are being developed. I enjoy the later years more, especially as Cecelia gets deeper in her thesis writing, but the first book establishes the tone well.
I haven’t really read the story in about a decade – so after COVID and the increasing taking advantage of workers desperate to learn and the debilitating student debt, some of these jokes are hitting different. Humor changes. Not good or bad, but different.
This particular set of jokes were originally written between 1997 and 2002. Therefore 22 to 27 years ago.
Amazon Cover
BOOK BLURB ON AMAZON for LIFE IS TOUGH AND THEN YOU GRADUATE
This book is the second collection of the popular comic strip Piled Higher and Deeper, which chronicles life (or the lack thereof) in grad school. Includes the popular strip series “Procrastin-X”, “Grad school makes you dumber”, “The Thesis Zone” and Mike Slackenerny’s improbable thesis defense. Bonus features include never-before published strips, author notes and a foreword by Karl Marx. Whether you managed to escape grad school, are struggling through it, or are thinking of applying to it, Piled Higher and Deeper will have you lauging and crying at the same time. Piled Higher and Deeper is published online at www.phdcomics.com, where it receives over 1.8 million page views a month from grad students all over the world.
MY REVIEW for LIFE IS TOUGH AND THEN YOU GRADUATE
For Piled Higher and Deeper comic, Chapter 2 covers year Six (2002-2003) to year Eight (2004-2005).
The cast of our intrepid graduate students continue in their quest for the golden diploma. Cecilia both fears she will never reach it and is terrified of passing the goal. The unnamed main character juggles both a career and research … poorly. Tajel continues her political fire while working on figuring out what her thesis could be. Dee starts grad school. And Mike Slackenerny … he has a baby on the way and a defense to present. Free food will not fill the void between the two forever. After decades, pressure is growing for him to produce something.
PhD continues with the highly diverse cast, with a mix of Americans and imports as often happens in PhD programs, especially in California.
I’m reading the story in 2024, written with 2005 technology … students still procrastinate with email instead of social media. With desktop computers with a single screen, just a few palmpilots to record information. It’s interesting how much the tech has changed over the years but the people haven’t.
If you like the series, you will like the paperback format.
Amazon Cover
BOOK BLURB ON AMAZON for SCOOPED!
The third collection of the popular comic strip Piled Higher and Deeper, which chronicles life (or the lack thereof) in grad school. Includes the popular strip series “How to write your Thesis title”, “The Scientific Method vs. The Actual Method”, “Valentine Gift Ideas for your Advisor” and many more. Whether you managed to escape Grad School, are struggling through it, or are thinking of applying to it, Piled Higher and Deeper will have you lauging and crying at the same time.
MY REVIEW for SCOOPED!
Chapter 3 of PhD covers years 2005-2007, with the back matter reporting on Dr. Cham’s college tour of 60 campuses (pp. 133-154). The college tour section is interesting to see the author’s illustrations change over time in a manner similar to chapter 1 as he learns a new format and story telling technique.
This is a story of the long journey to the special diploma via making a huge (or minuscule but at least unique, mostly, unless you are scooped and then pivoting on the fly unless you discover they didn’t really do your work, probably) addition to humanity’s knowledge and, for some of our intrepid graduate students, endings. Cecilia’s love of her life ends up being a toss up between her quest for technology and another human being. Mike Slackenerny pressure from wife and child and funding and professor needing to show progress finally culminates in words on screen and paper.
The author continues to grow in storytelling skills and the skits gets longer and more complicated. He has to trade off the consistency of the world-building environment with pushing forward to create new jokes and plotline advancement to maintain interest, which he does well.
Overall, another good steady release for the PhD comics.
Amazon Cover
BOOK BLURB ON AMAZON for ACADEMIC STIMULUS PACKAGE
The fourth collection of the popular comic strip Piled Higher and Deeper, which chronicles life (or the lack thereof) in academia. Includes the popular strip series Quantum Gradnamics, ANOVA: Analysis of Value, Seminar Bingo and many more. Whether you managed to escape academia, are struggling through it, or are thinking of applying to it, this smart comic strip will have you laughing all the way.
MY REVIEW for ACADEMIC STIMULUS PACKAGE
Another solid addition to the PhD comic collection with Chapter 4: Academic Stimulus Package. This particular volume covers the strips from 2007-2009 – I’m reading and reviewing it in 2024.
I think overall this is the best so far, but it could just be the introduction of so many graphs. As any graduate student will tell you, adding graphs to prose can get you all sorts of upticks with your advisors. Graphs are seductive.
Technology continues to advance and the characters are finally hitting the commonplace stuff we use today (2024). Facebook makes its first appearance as a time waster for our unnamed protagonist’s procrastination. He also adds a second monitor and is thinking about a third. Plus the new monitor is a flatscreen rather than the cathode ray tubes monitor us readers have seen taking up huge amounts of space on the desks of our favorite graduate students.
The back matter, like last time, includes information about Dr. Cham’s book tours. The big difference this time is including comic-strip overviews of dissertations and experiments people shared with him during his travels including working with colliders in search of the Higgs-Boson (confirmed in 2012/2013 at CERN, the very place Dr. Cham visited in 2008), how research time works at telescopes, and using cancer cells to measure uranium leakage into ground water. — This fascinating information providing a jumping off point for Jorge Cham’s later interest of creating scientific fact sharing books like “We have No Idea” in 2017 on top of the PhD comics.
Watching authors evolve in interest and ability always fascinates me.
Best of all – the biggest advancement in the technology – is COLOR!!!!
Amazon Cover
BOOK BLURB ON AMAZON for ADVENTURES IN THESISLAND
Life in Academia never seemed livelier than in this humorous take on grant writing, academic dress codes and the many uses for lab coats. Follow the phenomenon known as PHD Comics in this fifth book collection of the popular online comic strip. What would happen if Newton tweeted? If TV ‘Science’ shows were more like real science? If research papers had a comment section? Also included are excerpts from the script of the recently released ‘The PHD Movie’ and author Jorge Cham’s comics journal of his travels and his detention by the U.K. border police.
MY REVIEW for ADVENTURES IN THESISLAND
Collection Five of PhD comics: Adventures in Thesisland continues the wonderful color and presents the years 2009 to 2012. The tech and social media have caught up with modern standards completely, adding Tweets to the procrastination mess. I found this collection the most relatable of the series.
Highlights:
1. PhD made a movie! (Go them!)
2. p. 27 – Why is this still my desktop? I finished my graduate studies fifteen years ago. And when did Dr. Cham visit my house?
3. Thesisland series – Alice in Wonderland side-trip is some of the best art done in the entire series.
4. p. 82 – Can I bottle the statistics on this and send it to all media centers?
5. p. 219-222 – Another of Dr. Cham’s travel log reports. This one is … scary? disappointing? frustrating? prophecy? A report of him being detained in 2009 and nearly not able to make his lecture schedule. When he shared what happened, readers around the UK and the US shared how many non-white academics are being “returned to sender”. Are tensions worsening because of the bigotry or is bigotry worsening because of the actions to avoid tension? “Still, I keep looking over my shoulder for some reason.” – most of what Dr. Cham writes is real life for amusement sake, but sometimes it is just real life.
As always, the series is funny for those who spent too much time in academia. Or in the hallowed and hollow halls of science. Highly recommend.
Amazon Cover
BOOK BLURB ON AMAZON for 20th ANNIVERSARY
Celebrate 20 years of PHD Comics with us! This sixth collection of comics continues the saga of Cecilia, Mike Slackenerny, Tajel and the Nameless Hero as they deal with tough advisors, frustrating undergrads and writing their thesis. This collection contains exclusive essays by Jorge Cham on why he started drawing the comics, who inspired the characters (including Prof. Smith!), and where all his ideas come from. Other highlights include PHD Comics’ take on Dr. Who, Les Miserables, and Downton Abbey. Want to know how many academics it takes to get a Powerpoint presentation to work? Or where you stand in the lab/department hierarchy? This book has comics for you. It also includes Jorge’s Tales from the Road comics and a handy guide to Academic Regalia.
MY REVIEW for 20th ANNIVERSARY
Unlike most 20th Anniversary Collections, this is not a cherry-pick of the last twenty years of the PhD comic strip, instead it is really Collection Six covering years 2012 to 2014. Note that while this is the last of the printed collections, Dr. Cham continued to make more strips and publish them at his website until 2021. Well, he really stopped sometime in 2019. No new strips were published in 2020 and only six more published in 2021.
In this collection he talks about the births of his son and daughter and how they impacted his strip in his author’s notes -so if the last baby was born in 2014, then 2019 would be having a seven and five year old (guessing) and 2024 (when I am reading this) would be a 10 and 12 year old children – maybe older. He switched to longer form stories, looks like the most recent one is “Oliver’s Great Big Universe”, and his FaceBook page is still active (unlike his webpage which doesn’t even include the 20th anniversary book). He gave us a career, over 20 years, of comics and academia humor; I guess he is allowed to start his second career (or is it third? – did his grad studies count as one?). We have really enjoyed the ride he provided with the comic strip portion of his life.
I loved this particular collection for Cecilia really cracking down on getting her thesis written. As someone in the publication industry, her struggles of getting words on screen is very real. p. 153 – “Ok, I need to transfer my thoughts from my head to this screen. C’mon, Write! — (she brings her head into contact with the computer screen) They’re Touching! Transmit! Transmit!” — I feel this to the depths of my soul every time.
Great collection. Sad to come to the end of this series readthrough. But it is a great collection, and a great collection of collections.